Research Article

Ethnicity and Cultural Heritage: Compatible or Conflicting Concept?

Elena Samourkasidou
International Hellenic University, Greece
Dimitris Kalergis
University of Thessaly, Greece
* Corresponding author
DOI icon 10.24018/ejarch.2022.1.4.10

Read Counter
360

Downloads
303

Citations

Share

Article Sidebar

Submitted 2022-06-17
Published 2022-08-02

Read counter = 360 times

Table of Contents

Article Main Content

Cultural heritage embodies every aspect of culture from the past, which has been incorporated into current society. Collective urban identity includes all those individual components of collective memory that leave their spatial imprint on the city. The paper aims to research the transition of cities from the multicultural Ottoman Empire to the formation of nation-states and the management of cultural heritage and urban physiognomy by each of them. Moreover, the preservation of the collective memory and identity of cities is a decisive factor in their evolutionary course.

The methodology followed includes the comparative analysis of 5 representative port-cities of the Ottoman Empire: Thessaloniki, Istanbul, Izmir, Beirut and Alexandria, where the element of cosmopolitanism is vivid. The searching period concerns the time just before its dissolution and the emergence of nation-states.

The paper concludes that the rise of nationalism and the conflicts between states that will result from the disintegration of the Ottoman Empire will irreversibly alter the population composition of these cities, which will evolve violently from multi-ethnic Ottoman cities to mono-ethnic cities in the 20th century. The abrupt emergence of nation-states resulted in the marginalization of key aspects of the cities' heritage in an attempt to create and consolidate new national narratives. This resulted in the dissolution of urban continuity in cities which affected not only the identity and self-definition of cities in global urban networks but also their development process and dynamics, depriving them of an important asset of differentiation and specialization. The lack of awareness of the importance of the cultural heritage of cities is also demonstrated by the fact that the Ottoman past should be a mere parenthesis in the history and landscape of them and is therefore eliminated from it.

Keywords: Cultural heritage, Collective memory, Cosmopolitanism, Nation-state, Ottoman empire, Urban identity.

References

  1. Achladi, E. (2006). From the First World War to the Greek administration: the end of cosmopolitan Smyrna, In Smyrneli, M. (ed.) Smyrna, the forgotten city. (In Greek). Athens: Metaichmio Publications.
     Google Scholar
  2. Anagnostopoulou, S. (2004). The Passage from the Ottoman Empire to the Nations-States: a long and difficult process. Istanbul: Isis Press.
     Google Scholar
  3. Anastasiadou, Μ. (2008). Thessaloniki 1830–1912, a metropolis in the age of ottoman reforms. (In Greek). Athens: Estia Bookshop.
     Google Scholar
  4. Awad, M. (1992). The Impact of Economic Change on the Structure and Function of the Building Industry in Egypt (1920-1985), PhD Thesis. Alexandria: Alexandria University.
     Google Scholar
  5. Awad, M. (1996). The Metamorphosis of Mansheya. at http://www.thewallsofalex.blogspot.gr/2014/07/the-metamorphosis-of-mansheya.html, (access 24/2/2018).
     Google Scholar
  6. Awad, M. (2008). Italy in Alexandria: Influences on the Built Environment. Alexandria: Alexandria Preservation Trust.
     Google Scholar
  7. Barkey, K. (2008). Empire of Difference. The Ottoman in Comparative Perspective, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
     Google Scholar
  8. Bilsel, C. (1996). Ideology and Urbanism during the early republican period: two master plans for Izmir and scenarios of modernization. METU Journal of Faculty of Architecture, 16(1), 13-30.
     Google Scholar
  9. Bilsel, C. (2006). A city is being reborn from its ashes: The creation of Democratic Smyrna. In Smyrneli, M. (ed.) Smyrna, the forgotten city. (In Greek). Athens: Metaichmio Publications.
     Google Scholar
  10. Botonaki, N. (2007). Policies of memory: Historical monuments as recording aspects of Historical and social memory. The monuments of the Municipality of Anatoli. (In Greek). Ioannina.
     Google Scholar
  11. Braude, B. (1982). Foundation Myths of the Millet System. In Braude, B. and Lewis, B. (eds.) Christian and Jews in the Ottoman Empire, the Functioning of a Plural Society. New York/London: Holmes and Meier.
     Google Scholar
  12. Coser, L. (1992). On Collective Memory, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
     Google Scholar
  13. Davison, R. (2015). Reform in the Ottoman Empire, 1856–1876, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
     Google Scholar
  14. Dessouki, M. (2012). The Interrelationship between Urban Space and Collective Memory: The Case of Alexandria, Egypt, Thesis. Cairo: Cairo University.
     Google Scholar
  15. Eldem, E. (1993). The Ethnic Structure of Galata. Istanbul, 1 (1), 28–33.
     Google Scholar
  16. Fawaz, M. and Peillen, I. (2002). The Slums of Beirut. Report submitted to UN-Habitat.
     Google Scholar
  17. Findley, C. (2014). “The Acid Test of Ottomanism: The Acceptance of Non-Muslims in the Late Ottoman Bureaucracy”, in Braude, B. (ed.) Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Empire, New York: Lynne Rienner Publishers.
     Google Scholar
  18. Fuhrmann, M. (2003). Cosmopolitan imperialists and the ottoman port cities. Conflicting logics in the urban social fabric. Cahiers de la Méditerranée, 67, 149–163.
     Google Scholar
  19. Georgelin, H. (2007). La fin de Smyrne. Du cosmopolitisme aux nationalismes. Translated by Malafeka, M. (In Greek). Athens: KEDROS Publications.
     Google Scholar
  20. Gottmann, J. (1969). Megapolis. Massachusetts: MIT Press.
     Google Scholar
  21. Güven, D. (2006). Nationalism, social change and minorities. (In Greek). Athens: Estia Bookshop.
     Google Scholar
  22. Ioannou, G. (1984). The capital of refugees, Athens: Kedros Publications.
     Google Scholar
  23. Kalergis, D. (2012). Cognitive Map: The base of forming urban representations. 1st Panhellenic Place Marketing and Place Branding Conference. Volos, 30.3-1.4.2012.
     Google Scholar
  24. Kalergis, D. (2015). City, competitiveness and architecture: the role of the Image in their promotion and development. (In Greek). PhD Thesis, Volos: University of Thessaly.
     Google Scholar
  25. Karadimou-Gerolympou, A. (1995). The reconstruction of Thessaloniki after the fire of 1917. (In Greek). Thessaloniki: University Studio Press.
     Google Scholar
  26. Karadimou- Gerolympou, A. (2008). The urban space of Thessaloniki: long durations and rapid transformations, in the context of the Balkan hinterland. In Kafkalas, Gr., Lamprianidis, L. and Papamichos, N. (eds.) Thessaloniki in the verge- The city as a process of change. (In Greek). Athens: Kritiki Publications.
     Google Scholar
  27. Karadimou- Gerolympou, A. (2016). "Aspects of the urban area of Smyrna before and after collapse: Obsessions and Ruptures", in Proceedings of the International Scientific Conference The development of a metropolis of the Eastern Mediterranean (17th century-1922). (In Greek). Athens: National Printing Office.
     Google Scholar
  28. Khalaf, S. (1983). “Some sociological reflection on the urban reconstruction of Beirut”, in Ragette, F. (ed.) Beirut of tomorrow: planning for reconstruction. Beirut: American University of Beirut.
     Google Scholar
  29. Khalaf, S. (1993). Beirut Reclaimed: Reflections of Urban Design and the restoration of civility. Beirut: Dar al-Nahr.
     Google Scholar
  30. Lamprianidis, L. (2008). The development of the city since the 80's: Why didn’t we exploit the opportunities effectively. in Kafkalas, Gr., Lamprianidis, L. and Papamichos, N. (eds.) Thessaloniki in the verge – The city as a process of change. (In Greek). Athens: Kritiki Publications.
     Google Scholar
  31. Leclair-Paquet, Β. (2013). “Beirut Divided: The potential of urban design in reuniting a culturally divided city”, at http://www.bartlett.ucl.ac.uk/dpu/latest/publications/dpu-papers, (access 24/1/2018).
     Google Scholar
  32. Macar, E. (2001) Smyrna: From triumph to tragedy (1919-1922). in Smyrna – metropolis of the Asia Minor Greeks. (In Greek). Athens: Ephesus Publications.
     Google Scholar
  33. Martinez-Garrido, L. (2008). Beirut Reconstruction: A missed opportunity for conflict resolution. At https://alnakhlah.org/2008/10/31/beirut-reconstruction-a-missed-opportunity-for-conflict-resolution/, (access 26/1/2018).
     Google Scholar
  34. Mavrogordatos, T. (1983). Stillborn Republic. Social Coalitions and Party Strategies in Greece 1922–1936. Berkeley: University of California Press.
     Google Scholar
  35. Mazower, M. (2006). Salonica. City of Ghosts: Christians, Muslims and Jews: 1430–1950. (In Greek). Athens: Alexandria Publications.
     Google Scholar
  36. Molcho, R. (2001). The Jews of Thessaloniki 1856–1919, A Special Community. (In Greek). Athens: Themelio Publications.
     Google Scholar
  37. Moskov, K. (1973). Thessaloniki 1700–1912. The intersection of the transformative city. (In Greek). Athens: Stochastis Editions.
     Google Scholar
  38. Polyzoidis, A. (2011). The moon went out in Alexandria. (In Greek). Athens: KEDROS Publications.
     Google Scholar
  39. Portokalidis K., Kalergis D. & Lalenis K. (2012). The Process towards forming Urban Identities. Contemporary Architecture and Urbanism in the Mediterranean and the Middle East (CAUMME) 2012 International Symposium “Global Impacts and Local Challenges”, Istanbul, Turkey, November 21–23, 2012, (pp. 105–122).
     Google Scholar
  40. Robertson, R. (1992). Globalization – SocialTheory and Global Culture, London: Sage Publications.
     Google Scholar
  41. Rossi, A. (1991). L' architettura della citta, Translated and edited by Papadopoulos, L., Papakostas, G., and Tsitiridou, S. (In Greek). Salonica: University Studio Press.
     Google Scholar
  42. Said, L. (2016). Heritage and Nationalism in Nasser’s Egypt: The case of Belle Époque Alexandria, Master’s thesis. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh.
     Google Scholar
  43. Samourkasidou, E. (2020). Urban transformations and evolution of Eastern Mediterranean port-cities (19th – 20th century). (In Greek). PhD Thesis, Volos: University of Thessaly.
     Google Scholar
  44. Samourkasidou, E. & Kalergis, D. (2021). Tanzimat Reforms and Urban Transformations in Ottoman Port-Cities. Sociology Study, 11, (6), 259–272.
     Google Scholar
  45. Schmid, H. (2006). Privatized urbanity or a politicized society? Reconstruction in Beirut after the civil war. European Planning Studies, 14 (17), 365–381.
     Google Scholar
  46. Smyrneli, M. (2006). A city in search of its history. In Smyrneli, M. (ed.) Smyrna, the forgotten city. (In Greek). Athens: Metaichmio Publications.
     Google Scholar
  47. Stamatopoulos, D. (2006). From Millets to Minorities in the 19th-Century Ottoman Empire: an Ambiguous Modernization. at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/234169305_From_Millets_to_Minorities_in_the_19th_Century_Ottoman_Empire_an_Ambiguous_Modernization_ (access 15/3/2018).
     Google Scholar
  48. Starr, D. (2005). Recuperating cosmopolitan Alexandria: Circulation of narratives and narratives of circulation. Cities, 22 (3), 217–228.
     Google Scholar
  49. Stathakis, G. and Chatzimichalis, K. (2004). Athens International City: From the Desire of the Few to the Reality of the Many. (In Greek). Geographies, 7, 26–47.
     Google Scholar
  50. Stavridis, S. (2006). Memory and experience of space. (In Greek). Athens: Alexandria Publications.
     Google Scholar
  51. Swyngedouw, E. (2004). Globalisation or ‘Glocalisation’? Networks, Territories and Rescaling. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 17(1), 25–48.
     Google Scholar
  52. Taylor, C. (1994). Multiculturalism, Princeton: Princeton University Press.
     Google Scholar
  53. Theologou, K. 2008. Space and Memory: Thessaloniki 15th –20th century, From traditional Communities in Urban Modernity. (In Greek). Thessaloniki: University Studio Press.
     Google Scholar
  54. Vaiou, N., Mantouvalou, M. and Mavridou, M. (2004). Athens 2004: In the paths of Globalization. (In Greek). Geographies, 7, 13–25.
     Google Scholar
  55. Yahya, M. (1994). Forbidden Spaces, Invisible Barriers. Housing in Beirut, PhD Thesis. London: Open University.
     Google Scholar
  56. Yannakakis, I. 1992. Epilogue: La mort du cosmopolitisme. dans Ilbert, R. et Yannakakis, I. (éd.) Alexandrie 1860-1960. Un modèle éphémère de convivialité: communautés et identité cosmopolite. (In French). Paris: Autrement.
     Google Scholar
  57. Zafeiris, Ch. (2007). The memory of the city, Thessaloniki in the 19th and 20th century. (In Greek). Athens: Gnosi Publications.
     Google Scholar
  58. Zivas, D. 1997. The monuments and the city. (In Greek). Athens: LIBRO Publications.
     Google Scholar